Symptom versus cause
There are moments when an organization feels that something needs to happen. Sales of a product or service decline, growth stagnates, or a change does not have the desired effect. This creates a sense of urgency and almost automatically a direction emerges: let’s revisit our positioning, refine our proposition, or investigate how customers perceive us.
That sounds logical. And sometimes it is. But the question that is always central for me
comes one step earlier: is this actually the problem, or is it a first interpretation of a signal?
What I often see is that organizations observe a development and immediately assign
meaning to it. Sales decline, so something must be wrong with our positioning. Response rates are low, so the message must be off. But that is precisely where the strategic work begins for me. Not by immediately working out how to optimize the chosen direction or deciding which research fits, but by first clarifying what question we are actually trying to answer.
It may very well be that positioning is the right step. But it may also be that the cause lies elsewhere, for example in changing consumer behavior, distribution or availability, price perception, or broader category developments.
For me, strategic thinking is not about doing more analysis, but about carefully
distinguishing between signal, interpretation, and underlying cause. This ensures that time, energy, and budget are spent on what truly makes a difference.
This does not have to be an extensive process. Sometimes a few sharp conversations and reformulating the question are enough to reveal alternative directions.
That is what makes the difference between research that creates value and research that mainly confirms what we already thought.



